"Like a schoolboy": Redknapp slams Martínez for lack of physicality

The former Ajax star has been a divisive figure among United fans since his arrival at Old Trafford, with his relatively small stature often being cited as a weakness. However, it was after the latest defeat that the criticism reached fever pitch, with several high-profile pundits weighing in on the debate.

Redknapp Slams Martinez

Former Liverpool and Tottenham midfielder Jamie Redknapp was particularly scathing in his assessment of Martínez's performance. "He's got to be tougher, Martínez," Redknapp stated. "He's like a little kid, he gets bullied around. He's a big header of the ball." The pundit's comments sparked a heated debate on social media, with fans divided over whether Martínez is good enough to play for a club of Manchester United's stature.

Carragher's Previous Comments Resurface

Redknapp's comments echo those of former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher, who had previously questioned Martínez's ability to cope with the physical demands of the Premier League. "He's not a bad player, but for a defender to be that height to play at that level of football... I wouldn't want to play alongside someone who is 5 foot 9 as a centre-half," Carragher had said.

Jones Points Out Aerial Weakness

Former United defender Phil Jones also joined the chorus of critics, highlighting Martínez's struggles in the air. "Firstly, he's a big header of the ball," Jones said. "There's a bit of vulnerability there on set pieces. Martínez is too focused on his man. Diogo Dalot steps a couple of yards towards the ball, maybe gets caught underneath the ball a bit and almost gets sucked underneath it."

A Divided Fanbase

While some fans have been quick to condemn Martínez, others have defended the Argentine, pointing to his impressive performances since joining the club. Supporters have highlighted his ability to read the game, his excellent distribution, and his leadership qualities.

What Next for Martínez?

The pressure is now on Martínez to prove his doubters wrong. The Argentine will be hoping to put in a strong performance in United's next match and silence his critics. However, if his struggles continue, there will inevitably be questions about his long-term future at the club.