A surprise at Old Trafford: United's shock managerial appointment

In the world of football, rumors and speculation are a dime a dozen. However, the recent revelation that Dan Ashworth, the recently departed sporting director of Manchester United, had favored Gareth Southgate as the successor to Erik ten Hag has sent shockwaves through the Red Devils' fanbase.

The news, first reported by The Athletic, has sparked a heated debate among supporters, with many questioning the club's decision-making process and wondering if they missed a golden opportunity to appoint a proven winner.

Ashworth's Preference for Southgate

Ashworth, a highly respected figure in English football, had worked closely with Southgate during his time as technical director of the Football Association. He was reportedly impressed by Southgate's leadership skills, tactical acumen, and ability to manage a high-profile team.

According to sources, Ashworth made his preference for Southgate known to the club's hierarchy, but his recommendation was ultimately overruled by CEO Omar Berrada.

The Case for Southgate

Southgate, who led England to the Euro 2020 final and the World Cup semi-finals, has a proven track record of success. He is widely regarded as one of the best managers in the world and would have brought a wealth of experience and expertise to Manchester United.

Southgate's calm demeanor and ability to handle pressure would have also been a welcome addition to a club that has often been plagued by instability and turmoil.

The Case Against Southgate

While Southgate's credentials are undeniable, there are some who believe that he is not the right fit for Manchester United. Some critics argue that Southgate is too defensive and lacks the attacking flair that is synonymous with the club.

Others point to the fact that Southgate has never managed a club at the highest level, and there are concerns that he may not be able to handle the intense scrutiny that comes with managing a club like Manchester United.

The Fallout

The news of Ashworth's preference for Southgate has led to speculation about the future of both men at Manchester United. Ashworth has already left the club, and there are rumors that Southgate could be approached by other clubs in the future.

The situation has also put pressure on Berrada, who is now under scrutiny for his decision to overrule Ashworth's recommendation.

The Verdict

It is impossible to say for sure whether Southgate would have been a success at Manchester United. However, the fact that he was the preferred choice of a highly respected figure like Ashworth suggests that he would have been worth considering.

The decision to appoint ten Hag instead of Southgate is a gamble that could pay off or backfire. Only time will tell.

The revelation that Ashworth favored Southgate over ten Hag has opened a Pandora's box of questions about Manchester United's decision-making process. The club's hierarchy must now be held accountable for their actions and ensure that they make the right decisions in the future.

As for Southgate, his reputation remains intact, and he will undoubtedly continue to be a success wherever he goes.